Key takeaways
- A Phase I under ASTM E1527-21 before closing supports CERCLA defenses such as the bona fide prospective purchaser defense; since the 2018 BUILD Act, tenants can qualify too.2
- Findings are reported as recognized environmental conditions (RECs), controlled RECs or historical RECs; E1527-21 reworded the REC definition around confirmed or “likely” presence and defined a “significant data gap.”4
- Timing matters: the inquiry must fall within one year before acquisition, and five components, including the site visit and lien search, within 180 days.5
- PFOA and PFOS have been CERCLA hazardous substances since July 8, 2024, so they are now within Phase I scope; the D.C. Circuit upheld the designation on August 18, 2026.36
- Large farm and forest tracts can use ASTM E2247-23, which EPA recognized for All Appropriate Inquiries effective August 23, 2024.7
- Wetlands, asbestos, lead paint, radon, mold and PFAS other than PFOA and PFOS stay outside the standard scope unless the user adds them.8
01What a Phase I ESA is and why buyers order one
Under CERCLA, the federal Superfund law, current owners of contaminated property can be liable for cleanup even if they did not cause the contamination. CERCLA protects buyers who investigate first through the bona fide prospective purchaser (BFPP), innocent landowner and contiguous property owner defenses. Each requires “all appropriate inquiries” (AAI) before acquisition under EPA’s rule at 40 CFR Part 312, and the BFPP defense lets a buyer acquire land even knowing of contamination if it meets the statutory conditions.2
ASTM E1527-21 is the standard practice most buyers use to satisfy AAI. EPA amended the AAI rule in December 2022 to recognize it, effective February 13, 2023, and ended recognition of the prior E1527-13 edition after a one-year transition, so current reports should follow E1527-21.19 A Phase I ESA is the routine first step in commercial real estate diligence, and lenders commonly require one.
Qualifying for a defense also involves continuing obligations after closing: no new disposal, compliance with land use restrictions and institutional controls, “reasonable steps” to stop continuing releases and prevent threatened ones, and cooperation with cleanup work and information requests. EPA’s 2019 Common Elements guidance explains how the agency reads these obligations, so a Phase I is necessary but not the whole story.10 See brownfield cleanup and liability protections for the defenses and state programs.
02What a Phase I includes
The assessment is performed by an environmental professional, as defined in the AAI rule, whose signed declaration is one of the time-sensitive parts of the report. It has four main parts:
- Records review: federal, state, tribal and local environmental databases for the property and nearby sites, plus historical sources. E1527-21 sets a floor of four (aerial photographs, fire insurance maps, city directories and topographic maps), reviewed for adjoining properties too where reasonably ascertainable.4
- Site reconnaissance: a walk looking for tanks, drums, stained soil, stressed vegetation, pits, dumps, wells and transformers. The AAI rule calls for visual inspections of both the property and adjoining properties.5
- Interviews: with current and past owners, operators and occupants and, where useful, local officials such as fire and health departments.
- Report: findings, opinions and conclusions, including data gaps and whether they are significant, meaning whether they affect the professional’s ability to identify a recognized environmental condition.11
The user, meaning the buyer, tenant or lender commissioning the work, has its own tasks: searching title for environmental liens and activity and use limitations, sharing specialized knowledge, and considering whether the price reflects contamination. E1527-21 expects the lien and use limitation search to reach back to 1980, the year CERCLA was enacted, or the report to explain why not.4 Skipping these steps weakens the AAI record.
E1527-21 also asks reports to name obvious uses on neighboring parcels and consider whether they could create recognized environmental conditions on the site.4 Where a data center tract borders a truck stop, rail line or industrial park, that review can matter as much as the site walk.
03Understanding the findings
| Term | Meaning | What usually happens next |
|---|---|---|
| Recognized environmental condition (REC) | Presence of hazardous substances or petroleum due to a release, likely presence due to a release or likely release, or presence under conditions posing a material threat of a future release4 | Often a Phase II investigation, negotiation or both |
| Controlled REC (CREC) | A past release addressed to regulatory satisfaction but with contamination left in place under controls | Review the controls and how they limit use or construction |
| Historical REC (HREC) | A past release addressed to unrestricted use without controls | Usually no further action; note in the record |
| De minimis condition | Minor condition that would not generally warrant enforcement action and is never a REC | No further action |
| Significant data gap | Missing information that affects the professional’s ability to identify a REC | Fill the gap if possible or weigh the uncertainty |
Commentators disagree on whether the “likely presence” wording widens the REC definition or only rewords it.411 Either way, a REC is not proof of contamination; it is a professional judgment, explained in the report, and it usually starts a negotiation or a Phase II.
The standard also asks the report to date each time-sensitive component. The 180-day and one-year windows run from the earliest of those dates, so a buyer can see exactly when an update is due.4
04Common issues on data center land
Many data center sites are former farmland, timberland or open land, and their Phase I findings are often limited. Typical issues still come up:
- Farm fuel storage: underground or aboveground tanks for diesel and gasoline at farmsteads and equipment yards. Federal UST rules exclude farm and residential motor fuel tanks of 1,100 gallons or less used for noncommercial purposes, and heating oil tanks used on the premises, so many are missing from tank registries and turn up on the site walk or in interviews instead.12
- Pesticide and herbicide mixing, loading and storage areas, and old chemical sheds.
- On-site dumps, burn pits and buried debris, common on rural properties.
- Fields where sewage sludge (biosolids) was spread as fertilizer, now a common source of PFAS findings in Phase I reports.6
- Former industrial, manufacturing or power generation uses, especially on brownfield sites near transmission infrastructure.
- Old pipelines, oil and gas wells, or pole-mounted transformers.
- Adjoining or upgradient sources such as gas stations, dry cleaners, landfills or industrial plants, which can affect groundwater or vapor.
Vapor migration from nearby sources is in scope, and E1527-21 puts more weight on vapor pathways, including from past uses of neighboring parcels.13 Brownfield sites can be attractive for power access, and contamination there is often manageable through state voluntary cleanup programs, but it should be understood before price and layout are fixed; see greenfield vs. brownfield sites.
Fig. 1Sample Phase I screen of a farm assemblage
Illustrative- PassParcel 1: croplandNo structures, tanks or fill seen; aerials show row crops back to the 1950s.
- WatchParcel 2: farmsteadOwner recalls a buried fuel tank; location and removal records unknown.
- FailParcel 3: equipment yardStained soil beside a diesel tank: likely release, reported as a REC.
- WatchParcel 4: woodlotDebris pile and drums on a 1990s aerial; buried waste possible.
- WatchAdjoining gas stationUpgradient leak case, closed; check vapor and groundwater direction.
05Large rural tracts, tenants and ground leases
Data center campuses often sit on hundreds of acres of farm or forest land, where walking every acre adds little. EPA recognized ASTM E2247-23, the companion Phase I practice for forestland or rural property, for All Appropriate Inquiries effective August 23, 2024.7 The standard sets no fixed acreage threshold: the environmental professional decides whether a tract fits, based on its size, character and likely concerns, and any developed portion that does not fit the rural definition still calls for E1527 methods.14 Practitioners describe it as a fit for large wooded, fallow or farmed tracts where records are unlikely to reveal much, and the 2023 edition was aligned with E1527-21.15
Fig. 2E1527-21 vs. E2247-23 for data center land
Most common
ASTM E1527-21
- Default practice for commercial property
- Site walk covers the property, on a grid or around observed conditions
- Four standard historical sources, also for adjoining properties
- Recognized for AAI since February 13, 2023
Large rural tracts
ASTM E2247-23
- Forestland or rural property; no fixed acreage threshold
- Site reconnaissance follows records review and interviews
- Visit targets areas flagged on aerials, roads and trails
- Recognized for AAI since August 23, 2024
Many data center developers lease land rather than buy it. Since the 2018 BUILD Act, a tenant can qualify for BFPP protection in three ways: through a landlord that is itself a BFPP, by meeting the criteria other than AAI where the landlord lost its status through no fault of the tenant, or by meeting every statutory criterion on its own, which means completing AAI before taking the leasehold.2 On a long ground lease, that usually means the tenant commissions a Phase I in its own name rather than relying on the owner’s.
06PFAS and the Phase I scope
Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) were the main open question when E1527-21 was published. The standard treats emerging contaminants as non-scope until they are defined as CERCLA hazardous substances, and then they move into scope.8
That has now happened for two PFAS. EPA’s designation of PFOA and PFOS as CERCLA hazardous substances took effect July 8, 2024, and on August 18, 2026 the D.C. Circuit denied the industry challenges and upheld the rule.3 The designation is in force as of this review.
For a Phase I, that means PFOA and PFOS belong in the scope: their confirmed or likely presence can be reported as a REC, while other PFAS remain optional non-scope items the user can add.6 A Phase I does not sample, so a PFAS concern found in records or on the site walk leads to a Phase II if the buyer wants an answer. On data center land, the questions are usually about history: biosolids on fields, past industrial use or a nearby landfill. Ask the consultant how PFOA and PFOS sources were screened and whether state rules reach other PFAS, since state definitions can be broader.8
07When a Phase II is needed
If the Phase I identifies RECs, the usual next step is a Phase II Environmental Site Assessment, typically scoped under ASTM E1903. A Phase II collects soil, groundwater, soil gas or building material samples to confirm whether contamination is present and how extensive it is.
Outcomes include no further action, a cleanup before or after closing, enrollment in a state voluntary cleanup or brownfield program, a price adjustment, an indemnity or escrow, or a revised site layout that keeps buildings, duct banks and deep excavations away from the affected area. Sampling and lab turnaround take time, so a Phase II has to fit inside the due diligence period, and the contract should allow an extension if one is triggered; see due diligence periods and purchase contingencies.
A buyer that knowingly acquires contaminated land as a BFPP still has to take reasonable steps after closing, so Phase II data also shapes the post-closing plan: capping, soil management during grading, or vapor mitigation under buildings.10
08Timing, shelf life and what is not covered
Under the AAI rule, the inquiry must be conducted within one year before acquisition, and five components (interviews, lien searches, government records review, the site visit and the environmental professional’s declaration) must be completed or updated within 180 days before acquisition.5 On long land deals, option periods and multi-phase closings, plan for updates: a report that was current at signing can age out before closing.
Fig. 3How long Phase I components stay usable
- Interviews and site visit0–180
- Lien and government records searches0–180
- Environmental professional declaration0–180
- Rest of the inquiryUp to one year
The standard scope also leaves out several issues that matter to a data center buyer. These can be added as non-scope considerations or handled separately:
- Wetlands and streams, covered in wetlands and data center development.
- Endangered species and cultural resources, which have their own review tracks.
- Asbestos, lead-based paint, radon and mold in existing structures.
- PFAS other than PFOA and PFOS, unless the user adds them or state law reaches them.
- Industrial hygiene, health and safety, and regulatory compliance for current operations.
A Phase I is one line in the site due diligence checklist. It is usually quick and inexpensive relative to the land price, so order it early enough that a Phase II, if needed, still fits. When we screen land, environmental history is checked alongside power, water and flood exposure; to have a parcel looked at, get a site reviewed.
Common questions
How long is a Phase I ESA valid?
Under the All Appropriate Inquiries rule, the inquiry must fall within one year before acquisition, and the interviews, lien searches, records review, site visit and environmental professional’s declaration within 180 days.5 E1527-21 runs the clock from the earliest component date, so check those dates against the expected closing.
What is a REC in a Phase I report?
A recognized environmental condition (REC) is the presence of hazardous substances or petroleum on a property due to a release, their likely presence due to a release or likely release, or their presence under conditions that pose a material threat of a future release. A REC does not prove contamination exists, but it usually leads to a Phase II investigation, deal negotiation or both.
Does a Phase I ESA test for PFAS?
A Phase I never samples. But PFOA and PFOS have been CERCLA hazardous substances since July 8, 2024, so a Phase I under E1527-21 should evaluate them and can report their likely presence as a REC.6 Other PFAS stay optional unless the user adds them, and any testing happens in a Phase II.
Can a data center tenant rely on the landowner’s Phase I?
Sometimes. Since the 2018 BUILD Act, a tenant can share a landlord’s BFPP status, but a tenant that wants protection in its own right must complete All Appropriate Inquiries before taking the leasehold. On a long data center ground lease, tenants often commission their own Phase I for that reason.
Notes
- 1.U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (Federal Register), “Standards and Practices for All Appropriate Inquiries (Final Rule, 87 FR 76578),” 2022. govinfo.gov
- 2.U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, “Bona Fide Prospective Purchasers,” n.d. epa.gov
- 3.Crowell & Moring, “D.C. Circuit Upholds Designation of PFOA and PFOS as CERCLA Hazardous Substances,” 2026. crowell.com
- 4.Environmental Protection (EPOnline), “ASTM 1527-21 Phase I Environmental Site Assessment Standards Update Summary,” 2022. eponline.com
- 5.National Archives, Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, “40 CFR 312.20, All appropriate inquiries,” n.d. ecfr.gov
- 6.Fox Rothschild, PFAS Blog, “A Year Later: How Is PFAS Being Addressed in Phase I ESAs?,” 2025. pfas.foxrothschild.com
- 7.Mitchell Williams, “Phase I Environmental Site Assessment for Forest Land or Rural Property: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Issues Final Rule,” 2024. mitchellwilliamslaw.com
- 8.Lowenstein Sandler, “American Society for Testing and Materials Adds PFAS Guidance to Phase I Due Diligence Standard,” 2022. lowenstein.com
- 9.Beveridge & Diamond, “EPA Amends All Appropriate Inquiries Standard for Phase I Environmental Site Assessments,” n.d. bdlaw.com
- 10.U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, “Enforcement Discretion Guidance Regarding Statutory Criteria for Those Who May Qualify as CERCLA Bona Fide Prospective Purchasers, Contiguous Property Owners, or Innocent Landowners (‘Common Elements’),” 2019. epa.gov
- 11.Quarles, “EPA Approves ASTM E1527-21 Phase I ESA Standard for All Appropriate Inquiry,” n.d. quarles.com
- 12.U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, “UST Technical Compendium: Applicability, Definitions, and Notification,” n.d. 19january2025snapshot.epa.gov
- 13.Katten Muchin Rosenman, “New ASTM Standard for Phase I Environmental Site Assessments Takes Legal Effect: What This Means for Scoping Due Diligence,” 2023. katten.com
- 14.TRC Companies, “Environmental Site Assessments for Forest and Rural Properties,” 2023. trccompanies.com
- 15.LaBella Associates, “Updated Phase I Standard for Forestland and Rural Properties,” n.d. labellapc.com
Have a site in mind?
Get a straight answer on your land.
Send a parcel number, an address, a map pin or a target load. We’ll tell you what it can support and what it would take.
This guide is general information about data center site selection. It is not engineering, legal, tax or investment advice. Requirements vary by state, utility and county, so confirm the specifics for any site with the relevant authorities and advisors.
Terms in this guide
Related guides
More in Environmental & physical risk
- Can You Build a Data Center in a Floodplain?
- Slope, Soils and Geotechnical Review for Data Center Sites
- Natural Hazard Risk in Data Center Site Selection
- Endangered Species Review for Data Center Sites: What Triggers It and What to Check
- Cultural Resources and Section 106: What Data Center Developers Need to Know
- Stormwater Management for Data Center Campuses: Permits, Ponds and Land Use
- Do Data Center Backup Generators Need an Air Permit?
- NEPA Review for Data Centers: When It Applies and What Changed in 2025
- Seismic Risk and Data Center Site Selection: Hazard Maps, Design Categories and Liquefaction
- Karst, Sinkholes and Data Center Sites: How to Screen and Investigate the Ground
- Tornado and High-Wind Risk for Data Centers: ASCE 7-22 Tornado Loads, Risk Categories and Siting
- Wildfire Risk and Data Center Siting: Hazard Maps, Power Shutoffs and WUI Codes
- Hurricane and Storm Surge Risk for Data Center Sites: SLOSH Maps, Coastal Flood Zones and Grid Outages
- Tree Clearing and Forest Conservation Rules for Data Center Sites
- Climate Change, Future Heat and Data Center Site Risk
- Data Center Emissions and ESG Reporting: What It Means for Site Selection
- Diesel Fuel Storage and SPCC Plans at Data Centers
Guide 5 of 21 in Environmental & physical risk · all 242 guides · glossary · calculators
